What anime should I watch based on what I saw so far?

You have the exact taste of anime as I do it's not even funny! I've seen all the ones you listed above^^ I would Highly recommend for you: Kuroshitsuji (black butler) : Just a stone's throw away from London lies the manor house of the illustrious Phantomhive earldom and its young master, Ciel Phantomhive. On the night of Ciel Phantomhive's tenth birthday, a fire engulfed his manor. The boy was missing for a month before returning with a mysterious black clad butler, Sebastian. The servant is actually a demon that had entered into a contract with Ciel, promising the boy to help him achieve revenge on the arsonists in exchange for his soul. Sebastian Michaelis, an exceptionally loyal butler, is ever at Ciel's side, ready to carry out his young master's wishes. As the Queen's guard dog and standing at the top of the British underworld, the young boy must face many difficulties along the way. Black Butler is set in the Victorian era, and carries with it the typical eloquence of its time. .. Bleach: too long to summarize but totally amazing (skip the filler arcs). .. Durarara!! Actually the first anime I ever watched (3 years ago)Mikado Ryūgamine, a young boy who longs for the exciting life of the big city, moves to Ikebukuro at the invitation of his childhood friend Masaomi Kida, who he has not seen since he was young, to attend Raira Academy with him. After meeting Masaomi at the train station, they both set out at night to the streets of Ikebukuro. Masaomi warns him about people he doesn't want to cross in the city: like a violent and superhumanly strong man, Shizuo Heiwajima, an information broker, Izaya Orihara, and a mysterious gang known as "The Dollars." After running into some of the side characters, Mikado witnesses a local legend called the "Black Rider", who rides around Ikebukuro on a black bike that occasionally brays like a horse and also rumored to have no head under its helmet. The "Black Rider" is Celty Sturluson, an Irish dullahan who is in Ikebukuro looking for her stolen head. The narrative follows all of the characters equally, showing how their lives intersect, creating a greater plot-line from what each character knows about a common incident. ... Darker than black (season 1) is Amazing,season 2 was not that good.Ten years ago, a mysterious spacial anomaly known as "Hell's Gate" appeared in Tokyo, altering the sky and wreaking havoc on the landscape. The real stars disappeared, replaced by false stars. During this time, people possessing various special abilities emerged, each capable of different supernatural feats - these are known as Contractors. Each Contractor has a corresponding fake star, which reacts to their activities. As such, Contractors are usually identified by their star's Messier catalogue number. Kept secret from the masses, these individuals are known to murder in cold blood, smothering unnecessary emotions with logic and rationale. Their incredible abilities, however, are gained at the cost of their humanity - Contractors are thus named because of an involuntary compulsion to "pay the price" each time their power is used, which can range from eating particular foods and completing meaningless tasks, to self-harm and changing their bodies in peculiar ways. Various nations and organizations around the world train and utilize Contractors as spies and assassins, resulting in violent battles for valuable objects and information.

Following the disastrous Heaven's War, the United States lost its dominant position as a superpower to a mysterious organization named the Syndicate. The story revolves around a Chinese contractor codenamed "Hei" as he undertakes various espionage and assassination missions in Tokyo under the direction of the aforementioned Syndicate. ... Throughout everything, death note was the best.

I was like you before, wanting to only watch animes similar to what I've watched before. But there are so many great titles that it would definitely be a pity for you to not experience them.

I'm currently watching, and enjoying:

- Cowboy Bebop, which people consider to be the holy grail of anime(it's great, but has not won me over just yet)

- Trigun

- Durarara

- Baccano

- Samurai Champloo

Also, I highly recommend checking out Darker Than Black. Very interesting anime with plenty memorable moments.

Hi I have an anime blog and if you click on the link Mal it shows all the animes I watched if you want to look at more anime. I would suggest

- Another (Gory alot of killing)

-Black Rock Shooter (fighting)

-Kuroshitsuji (i will admit its kind of boring in the 1st series but it gets better I promise)

-Guilty Crown

-Code Breaker

It seem like youre into Mysterious Genre kind of anime and the ones where you have to think.

-Persona 4 The Animation(English or Dubbed)

-Psycho-Pass(Subbed)

-Steins;Gate(English or Dubbed)

-Another(Subbed)