Yahoo Clever wird am 4. Mai 2021 (Eastern Time, Zeitzone US-Ostküste) eingestellt. Ab dem 20. April 2021 (Eastern Time) ist die Website von Yahoo Clever nur noch im reinen Lesemodus verfügbar. Andere Yahoo Produkte oder Dienste oder Ihr Yahoo Account sind von diesen Änderungen nicht betroffen. Auf dieser Hilfeseite finden Sie weitere Informationen zur Einstellung von Yahoo Clever und dazu, wie Sie Ihre Daten herunterladen.
Who can explain the negative effect of speculation in financial markets?
Many renowned economists mention hedge funds and other speculators on financial markets as one of the main reasons for economic crises, poverty, inequality and so on in this world. So far I have looked in vain for a good explanation for this phenomenon. Can somebody give an example of how speculators make money by impoverishing others?
So far, my understanding of stock markets was that he who gives a realistic judgement about the value of a stock or other financial product will win in the long run, while those speculators who push up prices to phantasy levels, will be losing eventually.
Thanks for your answers so far. To make my question more specific: I would like to know about the "dirty" investment strategies that speculators use, which cause economic crises and impoverish others.
"Pump and dump" is probably one of them, but this strategy won't affect any serious investor, will it? Generally any investor should make up their own opinion about the value of stocks, and be very careful when listening to random people's recommendations, because any stock market recommendation carries a risk of conflict of interest. So those speculators with "pump and dump" strategy will fool only those investors that only look at the price curve instead of looking at the real value of a stock. Those deserve to be fooled, I'd say.
Then, there was a debate about speculation of agricultural futures, and its negative impact on nutrition in Africa. So let's assume speculators artificially inflate prices of futures on agricultural products. Hig
My comment got cut off. So about speculation with agricultural futures, and its negative impact on nutrition in Africa. So let's assume speculators artificially inflate prices of futures on agricultural products. High prices for agricultural futures will encourage farmers to invest in increasing their crop yields. At some point, the inflated futures will reach their due date, and speculators will be sitting on hundreds of tons of physical wheat, corn, etc., which they will have to sell before it turns bad, otherwise they'd make huge losses. Selling under time pressure will push prices down, so isn't it that those speculators are actually making losses at the benefit of the distributors and end customers?
4 Antworten
- Anonymvor 8 Jahren
Money in the stock market is made from volatility- the amount of fluctuation in stock prices, commodities, currencies etc. Funds, speculators and others can make money when the economy is going up as well as when the economy is going down ( this can be done by using put options for example). If the market was flat without any peaks or troughs, then there wouldn't be a lot of money to be made. It is not only speculators who make the markets move, the government plays a big role in boosting an economy as well as putting it into recession. A government always wants the countries economy to grow, but they know if the growth is too aggressive, then the inflation will be too high and the cost of living will be very high - people will stop spending. Then there will be a crash in the economy.
The main reason that speculators move the economy up and down and put others in poverty is so that they can make money- disgusting but true unfortunately.
Quelle(n): Years of market trading and analysing - vor 8 Jahren
The negative effect of speculation is that the markets bubbles on the speculative predictions. Once the bubble bursts, which is expected as it is only a bubble, the holder at that point of time, looses most of his investments.
- vor 8 Jahren
Yeah, they'll lose eventually, but nothing that an annual bonus twice their salary wont fix.
- Anonymvor 8 Jahren
"Pump and Dump",..and Skimming..
They didn't lose eventually,..especially hedge-funds..That's a fantasy you guys tell each other....