Is the aim of Iran to "Persianize" Islam?

Question

The Shias drew sayyenda Ali and Alhussein may Allah be pleased with them, and they gave them Persian facial features, may Allah paralyze their hands for such a horrid deed. Moreover, the Shia books praise the Persians as if Islam and the Quran were revealed in Iran, ignoring the fact the The Prophet pbuh and Ahululbayt were Arab and had no Persian relation whatsoever, not to mention that the Quran was revealed in Arabic.

Furthermore, The Persian nationalist (Zoarostrian Shia) authors forge Hadiths stating that Allah swt speaks Persian when he is happy and Arabic when he is angry!!  Astaghferullah

Isn't that evidence enough to you, Shia friends, that the Shia religion is nothing but a political movement in favor for Iran and the Zionists?

kaqhnck dnqknckqj · Accepted Answer

No I have to disagree!!! This assumption does not make any sense, in fact it was Islam who aimed to Arabize Iranians! Islam is a Pan-Arab propaganda and it's still trying to destroy Iranian culture and language. Why are they so many Arabic words in Persian language? Why did Muslims attack Persia, while they could just introduce Islam to  Iranians and let them decide peacefully if they wanted to convert to Islam? Why do Muslims call Persian Gulf, Arabian Gulf? The answer is simple: Pan-Arabism.

Y-B · Answer

As an Azerbaijani Turk and Iranian citizen, I should say that refering to Hadiths is usual between shias but these saying (Hadiths) are so numerous and unlimited. The Shia religion, in contrast Sunnite, doesn't refer only to Quran book and they claim that Quran have ambiguous structure and this hadiths help Muslims to complete their duties.  In past, any one in any place could produce hadiths and claim that these hadiths are original but we all know that all these saying are personal pretense.
I am atheist but my parents are shia and the exploitation from religion in history of Iran has been current. I think the most important reason of present-day Totalitarianism in Iran is use of these religious factors. For example, one of these hadiths has been used for assimilating of non-Persians and has been printed over money paper of Iran (50000 rial):
According to this hadith, Muhammad prophet of Islam has said: men from land of Pars (Persia) will gain the science, Even if it (science) is in Thurayya (brightest star in the constellation Perseus, the Warrior).

? · Answer

Shias don't consider their books with 100% accuracy while other Muslim sects consider their books 100% accurate. One fake hadith doesn't proof that the whole sect is wrong.

http://www.al-islam.org/shiism/

P.S.

Thank you Truth Seeker! For increasing my knowledge about those Saudi Munafiqeen.

? · Answer

Salam

Please quote the Arabic versions of those Hadeeth so I can check their Gradings..
Unless you prove those Hadeeth to be authentic, your argument stands null and void..

______

How much do you know about the history of Iran/Persia?
There was only one ruler from the Safavids who oppressed Sunnis, and May Allah give him what he deserves..
Why do you think did the Scholars of Qom raise a revolution against the Western backed Dictator, Raza Shah?
Was it just to 'Persianize' Islam?
Watch this documentary whenever you have the time:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCZ-jmDbjmQ&p=7802C973C63A2C06&playnext=1&index=1

Anonym · Answer

The greatest risk and insult to Islam are these idiots...I wonder which group they belong to...offer your mummy to your friends...

http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/n.php?n=saudi-clerics-battle-over-adult-breastfeeding-music-fatwas-2010-06-30

Anonym · Answer

Salam.

Persian nationality as nothing to do with Islam(Shia), majority of Shia are not Persians

Sunnitism and Sunnites collected traditions from Jews and Christians

http://www.islamic-awareness.org/Hadith/Ulum/israel.html

Wa'Salam

Tebriz · Answer

i'm fairly certain if Salman e Parsi (May Allah be pleased with him) wasn't from Persia, they would curse him too and call him kaffir lol hahahaha

Is the aim of Iran to "Persianize" Islam?

7 Antworten