Yahoo Clever wird am 4. Mai 2021 (Eastern Time, Zeitzone US-Ostküste) eingestellt. Ab dem 20. April 2021 (Eastern Time) ist die Website von Yahoo Clever nur noch im reinen Lesemodus verfügbar. Andere Yahoo Produkte oder Dienste oder Ihr Yahoo Account sind von diesen Änderungen nicht betroffen. Auf dieser Hilfeseite finden Sie weitere Informationen zur Einstellung von Yahoo Clever und dazu, wie Sie Ihre Daten herunterladen.
Did everything come from nothing or did something always exist?
The Universe consists of matter, time and space.
Einstein showed than time and space are of the same thing (spacetime) and he also showed that matter is a manifestation of energy.
Energy can be converted to Matter and vice verse.
So space-time has to have a beginning at the big bang or as a believer will argue as god created the universe. But it’s different with matter as a manifestation of energy.
So here is the kicker question did energy have a beginning?
Does energy need time and space to exist?
For everything to have a cause energy is needed. All cause effect relationships transfer energy from one thing to another. (Fundamental law of physics). So for everything to have a beginning including matter, time and space there have to be energy present. So all energy that exists now must had existed at the beginning. Because the first law of thermodynamics stated that energy can’t be crated or destroyed. So energy must has always been here. Now the question out of this conclusions is.
Where did the energy to crate the Universe come from?
If your answer is from god than what exactly is the relationship between god and energy?
If your answer he is the source of energy? If that’s true does it mean he gave up some or all of his energy to crate the universe. Either that or good itself is an infinite supply of energy so that I wouldn’t lose any energy as he created the universe.
This would mean two things: Energy can be crated or energy can be infinite.
Crating Energy would violate the laws of physics that ALL arguments for his existence that involves the laws of physics are irrelevant!
Because you would use the laws of physics to prove something that must violate them.
Lets suggest for the sake of the argument that god at least at part is an infant supply of energy. That would make sense because god is all powerful. This implies that energy can be infant. So back to our important question:
What is the explanation for the energy that was present at the beginning of the universe?
There are just 2 possibilities: It’s a supernatural or it’s an unknown natural explanation.
The Christians will know state that this energy comes from god specifically the Christian god.
But this is the Question that human being has been asking about a lot of things since human beings starting asking questions. What is lightning? Why do mothers give birth? Why does the sun rise? Why people get sick?
There are millions of questions we can ask and all of them could simply rushed of with god did it. But that doesn’t mean that this explanation is correct. In fact time after time after time the answer has been an unknown natural explanation that eventually becomes known.
Doesn’t it make sense that this trend would continue?
If you are fundamental believer you might claim to know with absolutely certainty what the source of this energy is and even claim to have a personal relationship with it. I simply say that the source is unknown possibly unknowable but that the most likely explanation is not a magical man in the sky but an unknown natural phenomenon.
From somecomputergeek
@evonne
A simple god did it is not an answer to my question
12 Antworten
- vor 5 Jahren
Technically everything that exists has always existed, just under another form... all matter was condensed and stuck together then the big bang happened and it just separated, then the laws of physics (gravity) made some matter get together again and form planets which then formed solar systems -> galaxys -> universe... even if you're just talking about earth and it's inhabitants then take piss for example it doesn't come from nothing but from the water you drink, all your body didn't use or got rid of through sweat has to come out at some point ... All those who refute what I said have the right to do so but remember that I have the right to have my own opinion just like you, if you explain to me why I am wrong I might change my opinion but I'm a very logical person so things like "you are wrong god did all that" will be ignored, things like "you are wrong god did all that and here's your proof and explanation" will be reflected upon...
- Anonymvor 1 Jahrzehnt
The conception of the 5 elements,
Which the mystics have always had, cannot be explained in scientific terms, because the mystics have their own peculiar meaning. Although the elements may be called earth, water, fire, air and ether, this must not be taken literally. Their nature and character, according to the mystics, are different.
Nothing n Something's
- vor 1 Jahrzehnt
noting can only make nothing correct?
so they say that nothing explode "big bang" and created everything... only nothing can create nothing so something always existed and created everything
something intensely power fully and extremely intelligent
i would consider one of the biggest problems
with evolution to be the fact that it discredits
the intelligent creator in favor of blind chance
and ill ask you how can blind chance create a seeing
eye?
even if you want to go with that and say that it just
happen, heres the problem if you believe that you were
unintelligently designed that there was no
intelligent hand in your creation
then that means you are a biological machine
a slave to the chemical reactions in your brain
which means you cant trust you thoughts
so if you cant trust your thoughts
how in the world can you claim that what you know is
truth
how can you believe in evolution
and claim that your belief is completely founded in
reality, when in fact you cant trust your own thoughts
the only alternative is you are created intelligently
and that discredits the whole evolutionary THEORY
if your inclined
go here this is your next step
youtube.com/user/venomfangx
- novangelisLv 7vor 1 Jahrzehnt
We don't know. There are concepts like negative energy and dark energy which are mathematical constructs, but which are not understood mechanistically. If there is is negative energy, that will balance out energy. We have mathematical models that address the nature of what might be beyond the universe, but no experimental evidence to back them.
- Wie finden Sie die Antworten? Melden Sie sich an, um über die Antwort abzustimmen.
- Lynn CLv 5vor 1 Jahrzehnt
GOD always existed, therefore God created everything, including our subtle little minds full of the knowledge that we got from the tree that was not suppose to be eaten out of.
still we eat from the tree, now GOD gives us the BIBLE the written word of TRUTH, and yet some still want to keep eating from the serpents tree.
- Anonymvor 1 Jahrzehnt
Christ is Risen!
Peace and grace be with your spirit.
"Ex Nihilo" Out of nothing!
Creation "out of nothing"
God of course is the source of all energy in the Universe/matter/creation.
Peace.
- Anonymvor 1 Jahrzehnt
If I was old enough to answer this question my birthday cake would be a volcano.
