Yahoo Clever wird am 4. Mai 2021 (Eastern Time, Zeitzone US-Ostküste) eingestellt. Ab dem 20. April 2021 (Eastern Time) ist die Website von Yahoo Clever nur noch im reinen Lesemodus verfügbar. Andere Yahoo Produkte oder Dienste oder Ihr Yahoo Account sind von diesen Änderungen nicht betroffen. Auf dieser Hilfeseite finden Sie weitere Informationen zur Einstellung von Yahoo Clever und dazu, wie Sie Ihre Daten herunterladen.
Are All Events In the Universe Pre-Determined by the Space / Time Singularity?
If all there is, ever was and ever will be forms objective reality, can free will exist?
4 Antworten
- vor 2 JahrzehntenBeste Antwort
If free will doesn't exist, then it would be pointless for you to ask this question.
If that's not enough of an answer, we're probably saved by the statistical nature of quantum mechanics. But, free will is not something that physics can address at this time. There's no data.
- ?Lv 4vor 4 Jahren
relies upon. Do you recommend its creation or its direction? in case you recommend creation then we move into metaphysics, in that the guidelines of physics do no longer practice pre-universe and the concept of reason may no longer be acceptable. We hence ought to invite no matter if pre-determined signifies that its existance grow to be predicatable and derivable from a previous ource (complicated, as previous implies a temporal component, and time in common words exists as a discernable theory after the universe exists) or that its existance is inevitable. for my area I area in route of inevitable utilizing proper right here obscure common sense: Pre-universe there is no longer some thing, no guidelines, no reason and result, no longer some thing. hence there is no longer some thing to ward off the conception of all or any feasable and self-sustainable possibilities. If there is no longer some thing to ward off, and no instigatory reason is major then if it may exist, it possibly does. may be proper, is possibly incorrect, yet its food for concept. in case you recommend is the approach the universe pre-determined, then ignoring the argument over the predictability of loose brokers the straightforward answer is convinced. Physics on the macro aspect is quite inevitable in nature. on the micro aspect we commence seeing quantum, it truly is a bugger. right here the concept of pre-determinism crosses paths with the observers paradox, in that we may be able to in common words see the position issues are or the position they're going. we gained't see both rapidly, and our commentary of both collapses the danger of the different. in this aspect the unniverse ought to be determined by ability of our common commentary, and so once back the argument over our own loose will emerges. On a very last note, this is been calculated that a pc or device smart sufficient to foretell the moves of the entire universe ought to ought to be the size of the universe besides, so no matter if the universe is pre-determined we gained't understand what is going to ensue, and the phantasm of loose will and chaos is maintained. desire that helped, for what its properly worth...
- vor 2 Jahrzehnten
No one knows what will happen next until it happens. And unless you were there to see something happen, you don't know who or what planned this for what reason or another. Things happen for many reasons, and you might just have control over them. This control is free will.
And isn't it free will that you asked this question? Or did something plan it to happen? My view of this is that you had free will over asking this question, as I had free will to just stumble over your question and decide to answer it.
Quelle(n): Me!!:)