When does the public's right to know outweigh a minor's right to privacy?

Question

It is not uncommon to read that the authorities are withholding the identity of a minor accused of a crime.  In the case of 8 year old Leila Fowler - allegedly murdered by her 12 year-old step-brother, the Calaveras County Sheriff's department held a press conference.  Although he is innocent until proved guilty in the justice system, the court of public opinion is a different matter.

So my question is: How do law enforcement officials decide when to protect the identity of a minor charged with a crime?

? · Accepted Answer

If the minor's name became public, it was likely approved by the parents.  Some do that.

Mr Placid · Answer

The sheriff is likely prohibited by law from revealing the minor's identity.   Undoubtedly, everyone in the town, including every reporter in Calaveras County, knows the name of the suspect.  The media is constitutinoally permitted to report the minor's name.  However, most media companies have a policy where they decline to publicize the names of minors accused of crimes.

? · Answer

All minors involved in a crime have their identities kept confidential. There is no decision that needs to be made.

garrytoo · Answer

it all depends if the minor is certified to stand trial as an adult.

When does the public's right to know outweigh a minor's right to privacy?

4 Antworten