Should Manly sign.....?

Craig would be a good person to sign but he'd be on tons wouldn't he and he seems to get injured a fair bit.

If I was Dessie though I'd keep young Foran there, he is something.

I think Wing would be a good buy he is a matchwinner and i think he still has some good footy in him, i agree with Blake they must keep young Keiron Foran he is gunna be BIG and Choc Watmough " the Best backrower in the world" is off contract end of season i think, but he will not go anywhere he loves his family and friends too much to move away from Manly, hey i think Souths have picked up Taylor "The human wrecking machine" from the Bronco's he would have been a great buy for Manly, but there will be a few bodies around to buy that can do the hard yards, by the way Punchy thats Chris Bailey not Luke matey, Enjoy ya footy everyone!!!!

Yer hes good and played origin this year. But hes been around for ages and must be getting on (I think hes 30). Id spend money on a young up and comer rather than some guy whos only going to drain your resources than probably retire after a couple seasons. Look to the future. By the way i was under the impression Wing signed with the Rabbitohs for 4 years meaning he isnt off contract until the end of NEXT season.

Depends how badly Souths want him and if they want to resign him (they should he's been one of their best players)

But i think Manly would tempt him with some big money. He would probably play 5/8 and push Chris Bailey back in to the backrow. A Wing and Orford halves combo would benefit Manly heaps i reckon. Players like Lyon will be used better outside a 5/8 like Wing because Wing knows how to position them and use them better then Bailey can.

I think Wing would be on top of their 'To get' list because even though Manly are losing mostly forwards i still think they have a strong enough pack without recruiting to many new forwards.

HANDS OFF WING!

As for the others, I don't know if there is a great deal of value.

Isn't the roster pretty strong as it is? I would have thought that Hasler has to change his gameplans quicker to adapt to injury or suspension...

If they had adapted to the loss of Stewart more quickly, they wouldn't have had as poor results in the weeks after he went.

The last couple of years Wing has been very injury prone so there is a risk for sure, however, at his best he provides great value for any club

I don't think Manly should sign him he would be asking for huge bucks.

Plus Matt Ballin is an 80 minute hooker I have never liked it when they change him for Le' Strange we lose direction.

And also Chris Bailey is pretty much a utility player.

Edit:Thanks Doc

As a Rabbitohs fan,i think Manly should sign Craig Wing,Rabbitohs dont need him anymore,cos he a weakling link in the team.

Word is, that if anything, he will be heading to Bradford next year.

Matt: I disagree. Your coach is what is holding you guys back.

Don't try make Asotasi do tricks. Just get him to run!

I think Craig Wing would be an assett to any team he is very talented.